Road kills in tropical ecosystems: a review with recommendations for mitigation and for new research

Resumen Si bien los caminos son indispensables para la civilización moderna y benefician a muchas especies de vida silvestre, han estado causando mortalidad por atropello desde que se inventaron los carruajes de alta velocidad hace 4 000 años. La mayoría de trabajos científicos en el tema se han realizado en ecosistemas templados, pero algunos autores han sospechado que hay diferencias en ecosistemas tropicales. En esta revisión, resumo publicaciones que se centran en muertes en carretera en países tropicales de África, América, Asia y Oceanía. Encontré 73 estudios pertinentes. El número de artículos aumentó después del 2011 y los países más productivos, en artículos per capita son Costa Rica, Colombia y Brasil. En muchos estudios, los mamíferos aparecen como víctimas más frecuentes, pero los anfibios sufren mortalidad masiva durante la época reproductiva y la mortalidad de aves es unas 20 veces mayor de lo que se creía. Cada víctima es un pequeño ecosistema en sí, lleno de especies microscópicas, pero la microbiología de fauna atropellada aún no se desarrolla como rama nueva de la ciencia. No se puede generalizar sobre el papel de la temporada o el hábitat en la mortalidad en carreteras porque los datos mezclados ocultan patrones individuales. Para evitar conclusiones erróneas, hay que mantener registros separados por año, sexo, especie, hora del día, época y lugar. Muchas víctimas son movidas por los carroñeros, mueren fuera de la carretera, o son demasiado pequeñas para ser notadas, por lo que no hay un solo estudio, tropical o templado, que pueda responder con certeza y precisión cuántos animales mueren, dónde o cuándo: sólo tenemos aproximaciones. Las contribuciones importantes de los estudios tropicales incluyen el énfasis ético en aprovechar los especímenes atropellados para investigación, la inclusión de especies que no son de vida silvestre, el estudio de aspectos poco entendidos (como el efecto de la hora del día y tasas de éxito y fracaso al cruzar la carretera, así como la eficacia comprobada de reducir la velocidad para mitigar el problema). La llamada "ciencia ciudadana" puede identificar las especies más afectadas, pero aporta datos muy diferentes de los generados por científicos profesionales en cuanto a proporción de grupos afectados. La reducción de velocidad es la medida de mitigación más simple y efectiva. Respetando directrices éticas, los científicos tropicales deberían concentrarse en el monitoreo conservacionista, y en el trabajo experimental para entender mejor la ecología de los atropellos y hacer un aporte que compita con el de los países ricos.

Abstract While roads are indispensable for modern civilization and beneficial for many wildlife species, they have been causing mortality from collisions since high speed chariots were invented 4 000 years ago. Most scientific work about road kill has been done in temperate ecosystems, but some authors have suspected that they have different characteristics in tropical ecosystems. In this review, I summarize publications that focus on road kills in tropical countries from Africa, America, Asia and Oceania. I found 73 studies that focus on tropical road kills. Output increased after 2011 and the most productive countries, in articles per capita, are Costa Rica, Colombia and Brazil. Most studies report that mammals are the main victims, but bird deaths are severely underestimated and amphibians suffer mass mortality in reproductive concentrations. Every road victim is itself a small ecosystem that contains thousands of microscopic species, but "Road Kill Microbiology" is yet to be developed as a new branch of research. No generalization can be made about the role of season or habitat in road kills because pooled data hide individual trends: researchers should keep separate records by age, sex, species, time of day, season and place; otherwise important patterns will be missed. There is not a single study, tropical or temperate, that can completely answer how many animals are killed, where, or when, because many victims are removed by scavengers, end outside the road or are too small to be noticed. Significant contributions from the tropics include emphasis on the ethical use of road kill for research, inclusion of species other than wild vertebrates, study of often overlooked phenomena like hour of day and failed versus successful crossing attempts, and the value of speed control in mitigation. The so-called "citizen science" can identify the most affected species but produces data that are very different from those generated by professional scientists in terms of the proportion of affected groups. Real speed limitation is the simplest effective mitigation measure. Tropical scientists should concentrate on monitoring and experimental studies to fully understand the ecology of road kills and to make a contribution that matches what rich countries do. Rev. Biol. Trop. 66(2): 722-738. Epub 2018 June 01.

Relación entre áreas y variables ambientales espaciales con el atropellamiento y cruce de la fauna silvestre en la carretera de la Franja Transversal del Norte, Cobán, Guatemala / Areas and spatial environmental variables related with the trampling and wildlife crossing in the Northern Transversal Road in Coban, Guatemala

Dentro del Proyecto vial de la Franja Transversal del Norte en Cobán se planea asfaltar 10 km del trayecto en el Parque Nacional Laguna Lachuá. Esto impactará a la fauna de no considerarse medidas de mitigación del atropellamiento. La investigación evaluó los patrones espaciales del atropellamiento de vertebrados, la frecuencia de cruce de aves y categorizó las secciones de la carretera en dicho trayecto, según variables ambientales (humedales, usos del suelo, cobertura; y ancho, asfaltado y ubicación de la carretera) con el fin de determinar los sitios más eficientes para la aplicación de medidas de mitigación. En el 2016, se realizaron 20 recorridos, donde se georreferenció, fotografió e identificó a los individuos atropellados; tres recorridos en los meses de febrero, marzo y abril, cinco en mayo y seis en junio; 12 recorridos fueron realizados adicionalmente cuantificando el cruce de aves para determinar que sitios podrían ser futuramente impactados. Finalmente, para un análisis más completo, el trayecto de la carretera bajo estudio fue dividido en 19 secciones (T1-T19) de 550 m cada uno. Fueron empleadas: estadística descriptiva, análisis de componentes principales (ACP), correspondencia canónica (CCA) y análisis de correspondencia (AC), para relacionar variables ambientales con atropellamiento y frecuencia de cruce. La mayoría de atropellamientos (80 %) ocurrieron en zonas asfaltadas, los anfibios fueron los más atropellados (125 individuos, 75 %), seguido por reptiles 21 (12 %), mamíferos 11 (7 %) y aves 10 (6 %). La mayor frecuencia de cruce ocurrió en zonas con humedales y alta cobertura boscosa (T1, T3, T6, T7 y T10) siendo estas secciones prioritarias para mitigación.

The Franja Transversal del Norte road project in the Coban Province plans to pave a 10 km long dirt road inside the Laguna Lachua National Park. This will impact the fauna if no mitigation measure for wildlife-vehicle collision is considered. The research evaluated the spatial patterns of the vertebrate´s roadkills, the bird's road-crossing frequency, and categorized the road section based on environmental variables (wetlands, land use, coverture; and road's width, location, and paved or not paved) to determine the most efficient sites for the application of mitigation measures. In 2016, 20 treks were made to detect, geo-reference, photograph and identify road killed individuals, three treks in the months of February, March, and April, five in May and six in June; 12 additional treks were made to quantify birds' road-crossing to determine the sites that could be impacted in the future. Finally, for a further analysis, the road section under study was divided into 19 segments (T1-T19), 550 m long each. A combination of descriptive statistics, principal component analysis (PCA), canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) and correspondence analysis (CA) were employed to relate the spatial environmental variables with roadkill and road-crossing frequency. Eighty percent of the roadkill's occurred in the paved zones, the amphibians were the most affected (125 carcasses, 75 %), followed by reptiles 21 (12 %), mammals 11 (7 %) and birds 10 (6 %). The highest road-crossing frequencies were related to wetlands and high forest cover (T1, T3, T6, T7, T10) being priority areas for the application of mitigation measures.

A fauna de vertebrados do campus da Universidade Estadual de Londrina, região norte do estado do Paraná, Brasil / The vertebrates’ fauna from Universidade Estadual de Londrina campus, northern Paraná State, Brazil

Este trabalho teve como objetivo fazer um levantamento da fauna de vertebrados do campus da Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL), pela compilação da literatura, com vistas a auxiliar o seu manejo e preservação. Foram registradas 250 espécies, sendo nove de peixes, 15 de anfíbios, 16 de répteis, 32 de mamíferos e 178 de aves. Duas espécies, o gato-do-mato Leopardus tigrinus e a jandaia-de-testa-vermelha Aratinga auricapillus figuram em listas de fauna ameaçada de extinção. A maioria das espécies, no entanto, não é estenóica ou endêmica da área, o que condiz com um ambiente perturbado e muito freqüentado pela população humana. O assoreamento do ribeirão Esperança, a redução de áreas verdes e a impermeabilização do solo podem reduzir a diversidade de espécies em médio a longo prazos.

This work had the objective to make a survey of vertebrates’ fauna from Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL) campus, for the compilation of literature, in order to help its management and preservation. 250 species were identified, being nine of fish, 15 of amphibians, 16 of reptiles, 32 of mammals and 178 of birds. Two species, the gato-do-mato Leopardus tigrinus and the jandaia-da-testa-vermelha Aratinga auricapillus, are in the list of species threatened by extinction. Most species, however, are not stenoecious or endemic to the area, which corresponds to an environment under stress and often visited by humans. Despite UEL’s rich diversity of wild animals, the burying of stream Esperança, the reduction of green areas and waterproofing of the ground can reduce de diversity of species in a medium or long term.

Caracterização florística da Reserva Particular do Patrimônio Natural (RPPN) Fazenda Carneiro, Lagamar, MG, Brasil / Flora of the Private Reserve of Nature Patrimony (RPPN) Carneiro Farm, Lagamar, MG, Brazil

A criação de reservas naturais no Cerrado é imprescindível para manutenção de áreas representativas desse bioma e para o desenvolvimento de estudos sobre a diversidade de sua flora e fauna. Este estudo teve como objetivo a caracterização florística e fitofisionômica da Reserva Particular do Patrimônio Natural (RPPN) Fazenda Carneiro, localizada no município de Lagamar, MG (17º57'-17º59'S e 46º45'- 46º48'W). A coleta de dados ocorreu entre os meses de novembro/2002 e novembro/2003. A similaridade florística entre as fisionomias foi realizada mediante cálculo do índice de Sorensen. Na área estudada são encontradas florestas ciliares e semidecíduas, cerradões e cerrados savânicos. A floresta ciliar é pouco representativa, cobrindo 1,7 por cento do terreno. Nessa formação foram encontradas 37 espécies (23 exclusivas) pertencentes a 19 famílias. As famílias mais representativas foram Fabaceae (7), Moraceae (6) e Euphorbiaceae (4). A floresta semidecídua corresponde a 21,7 por cento da vegetação local, apresentando 100 espécies (52 exclusivas) distribuídas em 35 famílias. As famílias com maior número de espécies foram Fabaceae (15), Melastomataceae (11) e Myrtaceae (10). O cerradão, devido a perturbações antrópicas, cobre apenas 4,1 por cento da área. Nesse ambiente foram encontradas 34 espécies (cinco exclusivas), pertencentes a 23 famílias, sendo Fabaceae (5) e Myrtaceae (3) as famílias mais ricas. O cerrado savânico, fisionomia mais representativa da RPPN, cobre 54 por cento da área. Apresentou 169 espécies (144 exclusivas) distribuídas em 46 famílias. Fabaceae (22), Asteraceae (18) e Malpighiaceae (15) destacaram-se por sua riqueza de espécies nessa fisionomia. A flora da RPPN Fazenda Carneiro foi diferenciada entre seus ambientes, pois os valores obtidos para o índice de Sorensen foram inferiores a 0,5 em todas as comparações. A variedade de ambientes apresentados pela RPPN Fazenda Carneiro e a riqueza da flora associada às suas formações...

The creation of nature reserves in Cerrado is important to maintenance of representative areas of this bioma and to development of studies about its flora and fauna. This study aimed to characterize the physiognomies and the arboreal and bush flora of the RPPN Carneiro Farm, located in the region of Lagamar, MG (17º57'-17º59'S and 46º45'- 46º48'W). Data was collected between November 2002 and November 2003. The similarity of flora was valued using the Sorensen index. The RPPN included gallery forest, semideciduos dry forest, cerradão and cerrado. The gallery forest is not very representative and occupies 1.7 percent of the RPPN. In this formation 37 species were found (23 exclusive) and 19 families. The most representative families were Fabaceae (7), Moraceae (6) and Euphorbiaceae (4). Semideciduos dry forest occupies 21.7 percent of the area and presented 100 species (53 exclusive) and 35 families. Fabaceae (15), Melastomataceae (11) and Myrtaceae (10) were the most important families in this formation. Cerradão, due to disturbances occupies only 4.1 percent of the RPPN. In this habitat 34 species were found (five exclusive) and 23 families. The families most representative were Fabaceae (5) and Myrtaceae (3). The cerrado, the most representative physiognomy of the RPPN, occupies 54 percent of area. This formation presented 169 species (144 exclusive) and 46 families. Fabaceae (22), Asteraceae (18) and Malpighiaceae (15) were the most important families. The flora of RPPN was different among its habitats because the Sorensen index found was less than 0.5 in all comparisons. The variety of habitats found in the RPPN Carneiro Farm and the richness of the flora of its formations make this reserve very important to the maintenance of biodiversity in the region of Lagamar.